In the past 24 hours, the GFS has changed significantly in its depiction of the upper pattern beginning on Tuesday of next week. The Euro (ECMWF) model has also been trending in a similar direction. Both models now agree on some form of a dominant western US trough that will begin spreading strong (greater than 40 knots) southwest midlevel flow in a jet somewhere over the Plains (at this point, central to northern). In response, southerly winds 'switching on' the low level moisture conveyor are shown beginning across the Plains on Tuesday and continuing through the week. I'm posting this update a little prematurely, since the 00z Euro won't be out for a couple more hours - but the information available right now points to chaseable setups returning to the Plains beginning on Wednesday of next week, and continuing possibly for many days afterward.
GFS 500mb forecast for next Thursday afternoon
It's a little early to get nitpicky about the details (like the GFS showing somewhat shallow moisture depth even into Thursday, capping issues and veered 850mb winds), but it's safe to say some Plains and/or Midwest chasing is becoming more likely next week. Given the flip-flopping leading up to this, it's possible the models could be playing one of their Lucy-vs-Charlie Brown football tricks on us all. So, I won't really start giving high chasing probabilities to this system until we get a few more days of model output.
The following table plots the chance of a Plains chase expedition happening in a particular date range (Midwestern chase days are not factored into this table):
2012 Plains Chase Expeditions - Probabilities as of May 18
May 18-21
2%
May 22-25
50%
May 26-31
30%
Midwest Chase Probabilities: The following table outlines the probabilities of a Lower Midwest chase (within 5 hours of St. Louis) happening within a particular time frame:
2012 Midwest Chases - Probabilities beginning May 18
May 18-19
2%
May 20-21
85%
May 22-25
50%
Midwestern chase forecast discussion(Update based on 5/18 00z data): A local low-key lightning chase still looks likely on Sunday afternoon/night in and close to St. Louis as a cold front moves through. Next week, a Midwest chase or two may be in the cards thanks to the potential upper system moving into the central US - depending on whether or not I'm able to make it out west for one of the Plains setups, if they materialize.
Regarding the Plains, there are a couple of chase forecasting items to talk about today. The first is an anemic trough that is slated to affect the central and northern Plains Friday and Saturday:
GFS 500mb forecast for Saturday afternoon
As you can see there, although we'll have some southwest flow for a time where we need it, it's just too weak to do us much good after the long-term ridging preceding it. We need a stronger trough to help create a good southerly fetch from the Gulf to transport deep moisture, then that same trough needs to provide strong mid and upper level winds above that moisture to create directional shear needed for supercells.
While the above configuration can produce chaseable tornadic storms given a few difficult-to-predict pulses of stronger flow, it needs the moisture component at the surface to be robust enough to a.) break the cap, b.) prevent too much mixing out, and c.) provide lower-based storms. I don't believe we'll have enough moisture to make for a great chase event on Saturday, but I'll concede that there *could* be a tornadic supercell somewhere in this setup. Is it worth a long trip? I don't think so. We're looking at one, maybe two if we're lucky, conditional chase days over Kansas and Nebraska. For me, I'm still not impressed enough to take a couple of vacation days to go for it.
Now let's look beyond the weekend. After many days of agreement on a chaser's worst possible forecast of a persistent 'death ridge', the models have been thrown into some confusion about what the last half of May has in store during the past 36 hours. This can be either good news or bad news, as eventually we'll see some pattern emerge from the haze. Will it be a good one, or a continuation of the doldrums of late? Take a look at this forecast that the GFS draws for next Wednesday:
GFS 500mb forecast for next Wednesday
I like the massive westerly jet over the Pacific. That's the type of energy that can do some damage to the current boring pattern entrenched over the Plains, providing those winds can amplify into a nice trough as they come on shore and plow eastward. The fantasyland GFS (past 180 hours) has it doing just that, but the Euro model has it staying rather flat and skipping over the ridge to the north like a flat stone on a lake surface. Unfortunately, the Euro model has traditionally been much more reliable in the long ranges, so I'm inclined to lean in its direction, as painful as that may be. The Euro's solution shows the broken record continuing, with the good flow staying too far north and deep moisture too far south to do any good.
What's worse, the Euro's depiction of temperatures in the southwestern US becoming a summer-like furnace does not bode well for the rest of the season. That region is where our EML (cap) comes from, and a 'nuclear' cap plus weak upper flow and struggling surface moisture simply means no storms when and where you'd want them.
The good news, again, is that the Euro hasn't been 100% consistent with this pattern (and the GFS disagrees), so things could still change. However, I'm simply not optimistic yet about a Plains chase for as far out as I can reasonably see.
The following table plots the chance of a Plains chase expedition happening in a particular date range (Midwestern chase days are not factored into this table):
2012 Plains Chase Expeditions - Probabilities as of May 16
May 16-22
5%
May 23-31
10%
June 1-7
25%
Midwest Chase Probabilities: The following table outlines the probabilities of a Lower Midwest chase (within 5 hours of St. Louis) happening within a particular time frame:
2012 Midwest Chases - Probabilities beginning May 16
May 16
2%
May 17-19
2%
May 20-21
60%
Midwestern chase forecast discussion(Update based on 5/16 00z data): The Midwest should stay fairly quiet through the end of the week. On Sunday and Monday, an approaching cold front underneath a little bit of upper support from the (weak) trough traversing the country should give our region a good shot at storms. As models depict it now, a lightning chase or two looks likely during this time.
When it comes to storm chasing and tornadoes, I'm a stats/numbers type, simply because I think the data is interesting to look at (particularly now that we're in such a boring pattern this May). 2012 has been a remarkable year for me personally in terms of the huge shift in total tornadoes by state. Kansas has always been my top tornado state by a long shot, with well over half of all of my tornadoes there through 2008. However, in just three seasons, Oklahoma has nearly caught up to Kansas in terms of all-time tornado intercepts. This is thanks to my being in the middle of a 4-year Kansas tornado shutout, while Oklahoma has gone crazy with tornado intercepts (14 in the past 3 years, 10 this year alone!).
Month-wise, May has always been my top tornado month, with June coming in second. However, April is also catching up in that respect, now tied with June for the #2 spot.
Here are some stats:
From 2004 to 2008, 26 of the 45 tornadoes I saw (58%) were in Kansas.
From 2004 to 2012, 21 of the 63 tornadoes I saw (33%) were in Oklahoma.
From 2010 to 2012, 14 of the 18 tornadoes I saw (78%) were in Oklahoma.
State-by-state tornado intercept data breakdowns for three time periods:
2004-2012 Tornadoes: 63
State
Tornadoes
Percentage
Kansas
26
41%
Oklahoma
21
33%
Texas
8
17%
Illinois
3
5%
Nebraska
1
2%
Missouri
1
2%
Iowa
1
2%
South Dakota
1
2%
Colorado
1
2%
2010-2012 Tornadoes: 18
State
Tornadoes
Percentage
Oklahoma
14
78%
Illinois
2
11%
Missouri
1
6%
Texas
1
6%
2004-2008 Tornadoes: 45
State
Tornadoes
Percentage
Kansas
26
58%
Oklahoma
7
16%
Texas
7
16%
Illinois
1
2%
Nebraska
1
2%
Iowa
1
2%
South Dakota
1
2%
Colorado
1
2%
Percentages by month:
2004-2012 Tornadoes: 63
Month
Tornadoes
Percentage
May
28
44%
April
17
27%
June
17
27%
September
1
2%
New Midwest forecast chase probabilities/discussion
I also decided I'd try out adding a new feature to the end of each blog post
outlining the probabilities of a Midwest/local chase (within 5 hours or so
of St. Louis). My definition of a 'chase' is one that involves deep
convection (thunderstorms), which includes lightning, hail, tornadoes
and thunderstorm-generated winds. In other words, subjects like dust
devils, auroras, sunsets and other photography outings are not
considered a true 'chase'.
The idea here is similar to the Plains
chase probability table, only focused more on the short range. The
Midwestern chase probability table will remain a year-round feature,
as chase days can happen here during any month or season. The
forecast discussion following the table may or may not be a regular
feature, but I'll include it as much as I can.
Midwest Chase Probabilities: The following table outlines the probabilities of a Lower Midwest chase (within 5 hours of St. Louis) happening within a particular time frame:
2012 Midwest Chases - Probabilities beginning May 14
May 14-15
2%
May 16
40%
May 17-19
10%
Midwestern chase forecast discussion(Update based on 5/14 00z data): As with the Plains, the lower Midwest should remain mostly quiet for the next week. Low-level moisture slowly improves each day, bringing a very slight chance for isolated thunderstorms each afternoon. However, the lack of mid and upper level flow and the absence of strong surface boundaries will make for very slim storm chances through Tuesday. On Wednesday, a slow-moving (and eventually stalling) cold front could provide some marginally-organized storms somewhere in the region. However, models indicate that these storms should be too marginal to warrant a chase if they occur outside of the immediate St. Louis area. Should this activity end up affecting the St. Louis metro area, a local lightning chase after dark is possible Wednesday night. After Wednesday, models show no sign of organized storms in the region that could trigger a chase.
The long-range models continue to show mostly bad news for chasers
through at least the next 10 days, as a strong upper ridge continues
to build over the central US. Strong mid and upper level winds
should remain confined to the extreme northern US, near and mostly
north of the Canadian border. Both GFS and Euro models show a
small shortwave trough developing and trying to move in from the Pacific by
late next week (visible on the GFS prog below), but the Euro shows it getting decimated as it runs into the
ridge, long before it can affect the Plains.
GFS 500mb forecast for next Friday afternoon
Despite the stubborn ridge,
moisture is shown as slowly recovering across the center of the
country day by day, but it is questionable that a sufficiently deep
moisture layer (robust enough to avoid detrimental afternoon mixing)
will reach northward all the way to the good upper support. The
situation is similar to late May of 2006, when shallow surface
moisture layers 'mixed out' by late afternoon, becoming too dry to
support anything more than high-based storms.
If deep moisture can somehow make the long trek in the weak flow to
North Dakota/northern Minnesota, wind profiles are supportive of
severe weather around Friday/Saturday of next week if mature storms
can get established. It may be a worthy chase day or two for those stuck on
fixed chase vacations or tours, but doubtful it will be enough to get
'on-call' chasers like me to pull the trigger on such a long trip.
My take on the current pattern is just to wait and make the most of
the downtime (saving money and vacation days; taking care of
day-to-day tasks usually neglected in the spring). Even if it ends
up being late June or not at all, waiting for good patterns to return
is always the better choice (in my opinion).
Despite the tornado/supercell threat across the Plains/Midwest being
close to zero for the next 2 weeks, some non-severe thunderstorm days
should be in the cards here and there, providing that moisture slowly
recovers enough to re-introduce daily instability. These conditions can provide
some nice low-key chase opportunities for lightning, cloud and storm
structure close to home, which of course I will be out for should they
occur at dates/times I'm off of work (it's doubtful I will use any
vacation days for these).
To sum things up, I don't see any sign of another Plains trip on the
horizon. Beyond the 'reasonable model horizon' of May 22, the
probabilities will remain at the standard 30%.
The following table plots the chance of a Plains chase expedition happening in a particular date range (Midwestern chase days are not factored into this table):
2012 Plains Chase Expeditions - Probabilities as of May 12
Well Im from maine and been hoping for some decent storms to come through. But when the forcasts look good, they fall apart and we end up with a stalled out front. Which brings cool weather and heavy rain. No lightning which blows. Do you think June will bring heavy storms to my area?. Because May looks like crap. - Posted by Tice jacques from Bangor, ME
Wednesday, May 9, 2012 - 7:34AM CST
Chase forecast update for May 10-20
Unfortunately, long-range models continue to show no sign of good chasing patterns over the Plains/Midwest for as far out as they can reasonably be useful (10 days in the case of the ECMWF). A western trough showing up at the far end of the range appears to be too far north to do much for the Plains in terms of upper flow, except for possibly Montana and North Dakota. At the same time, a weak upper low/trough shown in the east blocks deep moisture return from the Gulf of Mexico, which would keep moisture from flowing that *long* distance north it would need to interact with that upper support (if it materializes).
Worse, the pattern shows no sign of breaking down for what could end up being the bulk of the month of May. Which is to say, there are no signs of progressiveness, but rather a indefinite period of ridging and stagnation of the upper pattern. As a result of this, deep moisture should remain too meager across the entire continental US for even weak-shear thunderstorm days.
All told, storm chasing prospects in the Plains and Midwest look grim for at least the next 2 weeks. The good news is, that rarely lasts, and we should start seeing some improvement in the pattern (or at least some hope on model forecasts) by the last week of the month. In the meantime, we're looking at some downtime for a while.
The following table plots the chance of a Plains chase expedition happening in a particular date range (Midwestern chase days are not factored into this table):
2012 Plains Chase Expeditions - Probabilities as of May 9
20 storm chaser web sites and blogs you should follow
With the new era of 'extreme-only' storm chasing taking over, the old ways of chasing have been, sadly, taking a back seat in popularity. Most of what is shown on television today, and therefore what the non-chasing public thinks chasing is, is this 'extreme only' variant. (For the record, I acknowledge this is not the fault of the chasers on these shows, but more of the producers' and writers' scripting things that way). As a result, most newcomers to the hobby in the past few years have adopted this brand of chasing. This is a style that defines a good chase strictly as one where they get up-close, extreme tornado video, and a 'bust' is one where they don't - even if they see tornadoes! (Yes, I have actually heard some new chasers call a chase a bust where they were a few miles from a tornado, but not close enough to get extreme video). To each their own, I say - but traditional chasing is not like the 'extreme only' chasing that most of the masses today know. To me, that's a shame - because the atmosphere has so much more to offer than just close-up tornadoes.
While nearly any chaser - new or old - would not pass up the amazing experience of safely getting close to a tornado (me included) when the opportunity presents, a 'traditional' storm chaser is thankful for *any* tornado he/she gets to see, no matter how close. Most traditional chasers also appreciate all aspects of storms - lightning, storm structure, sunset-lit cumulonimbus, ominous shelf clouds, and more. Just being on the open road of the Plains and Midwest is enjoyable to most of us. Traditional chasing is much more low-key, mellow and cultured than what you see in media. It has its moments of excitement and intensity, to be sure - but it's not a constant adrenaline rush. The chasing experience is rounded out with times of awe, wonder, beauty and peacefulness - aspects of the hobby that I'm not sure I've ever seen portrayed on TV after the late 1990s.
I did a little surveying of the Facebook pages of many of the newer chasers and chase teams, and they almost without exception will follow only other 'extreme' chasers of recent TV fame. Some have likely never even heard of the names that helped introduce 'traditional' storm chasing to many of the rest of us. Hopefully I can make those introductions here for at least a few newcomers.
On that note, I wanted to highlight some of the lesser-known but highly respected chasers (at least, the ones I respect), and encourage newcomers to the hobby (and followers of chasing) to not only give their sites a good read, but 'like' their Facebook pages and follow their blogs. These are chasers who get far less recognition than deserved in terms of how much they have inspired, educated and influenced many of us (who came into the hobby before the era of 'extreme-only' chasing), and continue to do so.
Note - this is not an all-inclusive list, just the ones I could find who had an online presence. Some of these chasers have Facebook pages that I'd encourage you to follow (look for the links on their site or search for them on Facebook).